This can be applied to our current lives as well. Having lived in wealthy suburbs of large cities such as Plano and Troy, it was hard to see past the blinds of prosperity created by the infrastructure, safety, and community. However, it was frequently brought to my attention that even in such places, there are those who are struggling to get by. For example, many kids still need free lunch since they don't have the finances to afford it themselves. Unfortunately, this gap and inequality will never be resolved, as the gap between rich and poor will continue to increase as more generations are conceived. I believe that it is important to keep these things in mind. After all, Thanksgiving has just passed and is a perfect time to reflect on all of the blessings we have in life to be able to be born into such social and financial statuses. I believe that Fitzgerald did this to not simply build onto the character of the world in which Gatsby lives in, but to also allow the reader to reflect on his or her own life and world.
Saturday, November 26, 2016
The Valley of Ashes
In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald uses the valley of ashes as a symbol to remind us that even though our story takes place within the rich East and West Eggs, that there is without a doubt a lower class that suffers at the expense of 1920's commerce and modernism. With descriptions such as "grotesque gardens" and "crumbling" men, it is without a doubt that this is a bleak and melancholy environment ignored and left to rot. With consumerism and greed leaving a trail of poverty, the citizens of the valley of ashes are the products of this world. Outcasts who do not fit into the societal norm of lavish living are left in a ditch with no way to get out- perpetually sinking further down.
This can be applied to our current lives as well. Having lived in wealthy suburbs of large cities such as Plano and Troy, it was hard to see past the blinds of prosperity created by the infrastructure, safety, and community. However, it was frequently brought to my attention that even in such places, there are those who are struggling to get by. For example, many kids still need free lunch since they don't have the finances to afford it themselves. Unfortunately, this gap and inequality will never be resolved, as the gap between rich and poor will continue to increase as more generations are conceived. I believe that it is important to keep these things in mind. After all, Thanksgiving has just passed and is a perfect time to reflect on all of the blessings we have in life to be able to be born into such social and financial statuses. I believe that Fitzgerald did this to not simply build onto the character of the world in which Gatsby lives in, but to also allow the reader to reflect on his or her own life and world.
This can be applied to our current lives as well. Having lived in wealthy suburbs of large cities such as Plano and Troy, it was hard to see past the blinds of prosperity created by the infrastructure, safety, and community. However, it was frequently brought to my attention that even in such places, there are those who are struggling to get by. For example, many kids still need free lunch since they don't have the finances to afford it themselves. Unfortunately, this gap and inequality will never be resolved, as the gap between rich and poor will continue to increase as more generations are conceived. I believe that it is important to keep these things in mind. After all, Thanksgiving has just passed and is a perfect time to reflect on all of the blessings we have in life to be able to be born into such social and financial statuses. I believe that Fitzgerald did this to not simply build onto the character of the world in which Gatsby lives in, but to also allow the reader to reflect on his or her own life and world.
Sunday, November 20, 2016
Pecola and Pecola
I can't tell you how surprised and happy I was when I turned to the last chapter of The Bluest Eye and realized that it was dialogue. While I was reading it, I thought that it actually was one of her friends. For example, it would totally be plausible that two friends would say "You’re just jealous." and "I am not." It wasn't until we were in the seminar and someone pointed out that she was talking to an imaginary friend that it was imaginary.
This spurred me to wonder why people would have imaginary friends in the first place or how people could have the cognitive and imaginative power to create entities that have their own thoughts and wills. After some research, it became that imaginary friends aren't something to be scoffed at. Statistically, 37% of children have imaginary friends, and, unsurprisingly, is largely due to trying to cope with traumatic experiences and fear. This can explain why Morrison would create such a friend for Pecola in the last chapter. Having given up everything in her life to achieve blue eyes, Pecola has found herself in a lonesome and unfulfilled life where her end goal of getting blue eyes has left her with nothing but more concern and obsession. To cope with this, she strives for confirmation with an imaginary friend to make sure that she has made the right choice in her life, but in reality, it's to comfort her. The use of an imaginary friend has allowed Morrison to translate these same connotations and meanings to the reader without having to full out say it.
This spurred me to wonder why people would have imaginary friends in the first place or how people could have the cognitive and imaginative power to create entities that have their own thoughts and wills. After some research, it became that imaginary friends aren't something to be scoffed at. Statistically, 37% of children have imaginary friends, and, unsurprisingly, is largely due to trying to cope with traumatic experiences and fear. This can explain why Morrison would create such a friend for Pecola in the last chapter. Having given up everything in her life to achieve blue eyes, Pecola has found herself in a lonesome and unfulfilled life where her end goal of getting blue eyes has left her with nothing but more concern and obsession. To cope with this, she strives for confirmation with an imaginary friend to make sure that she has made the right choice in her life, but in reality, it's to comfort her. The use of an imaginary friend has allowed Morrison to translate these same connotations and meanings to the reader without having to full out say it.
Sunday, November 13, 2016
Are prostitutes bad?
Similar to how our views on beauty are subjective to society, our views on prostitution have been one of negative connotation due to social norms, but have you ever wondered why?
While reading The Bluest Eye, I noticed many references to the prostitutes China, Poland, and Maginot Line. Specifically, there was a remark made by the narrator in that they "had no word for innocence" yet had no "hearts of gold." Morrison means to suggest that they are not to be pitied on as products of a bad society yet they aren't complete disgraces to society.
I agree with Morrison since I believe that prostitutes are nothing more than ordinary people trying their best to make a living and provide for themselves or even a family. It just so happens that they are taking part in an "unorthodox" profession. And what's the harm of having them? Are they really harming society in the fact that they simply exist? I feel as if one of the main reasons people dislike prostitutes is that they encourage the degrading and objectification of women. However, I don't agree with this since it is not done without consent. It's not as if this is sexual assault done against the woman's will. Another argument is that the prostitutes themselves are being mistreated and are being exploited for their bodies. Although there are some instances where they are being forced by a pimp to continue their work, it is either because they have no other option to sustain themselves or in Morrison's words "looked back on their own youth as a period of ignorance, and regretted that they had not made more of it." In life, there are many paths and choices to make. Prostitutes have simply made poor life choices and should not be a subject of sympathy. This being said, I am not saying that they should be discriminated against, but merely left to their own spiritual demise.
Sunday, November 6, 2016
What's appropriate?
An even bigger controversy than whether race is socially constructed or not, schools across the world debate on the appropriateness of explicit and higher level text.

Personally, I believe that the cause of this problem in a nutshell is over sensitivity and fear. These two go hand in hand and cannon exist without the other. Over sensitivity stems from the fear that the reaction to such things would result in negative and damaging effects and vice versa. However, if the world was to realize that this was essential to the development of intellectual independence, things would change. I strive for the change of biased thought and societal influence on the way we perceive things. I realize that this is literally an impossible task given the fact that everything, even history, has sprinkles of bias since to recount something such as history must come with bias. However, the less filter that the government has on our lives, the better.
There lies two sides to this debate. The first is that children should not be exposed and would be harmed given that they are introduced to sketchy and controversial topics. On the contrary, the other opinion is that with the exposure to these subjects, kids are empowered with education to have a more realistic outlook on the world. In addition to this, the ability to deeply analyze carry on to all facets of life far beyond the classroom.
Personally, I believe that the cause of this problem in a nutshell is over sensitivity and fear. These two go hand in hand and cannon exist without the other. Over sensitivity stems from the fear that the reaction to such things would result in negative and damaging effects and vice versa. However, if the world was to realize that this was essential to the development of intellectual independence, things would change. I strive for the change of biased thought and societal influence on the way we perceive things. I realize that this is literally an impossible task given the fact that everything, even history, has sprinkles of bias since to recount something such as history must come with bias. However, the less filter that the government has on our lives, the better.
On a less serious way of looking at it, I enjoy it when we read these kinds of books since they aren't the conventional story books that we would read in middle school. In fact, I look forward to these kinds of classes in that I know that they will push the boundaries of what's socially right and wrong. I respect Valentino in that she challenges the status quo and would give us a book such as The Bluest Eye. Nobel prize winning authors shouldn't be judged based on against lines such as "young girls in whores' clothing," but rather their themes and messages.
Sunday, October 30, 2016
I'm a Barbie Girl, in a Barbie World
Once upon a time, as soon as humans were around, the patriarchy was what ruled the land; unfortunately, traces of that society still linger and affect everyone today. Faster than ever, feminism is on a roll to seeking gender equality between men and women. From the already achieved voting rights to the aspired equal pay, women are uniting in a movement comparable to the Civil Rights Movement.
Emily Prager, through the use of argumentative rhetorical questions, questions the integrity of the iconic Barbie Doll in its use of promoting a man-dominated world. Remarking on a man's design of an unrealistic depiction of an ideal woman, she draws a contrast between her obvious sexual features and the lack of such on Ken. While Barbie has "something indescribably masculine about her-dare I say it, phallic," Ken is missing something: his Jesus given pink elephant.
She suggests that there's a prejudice against women in that they can be viewed as sexual objects but men cannot. This can be seen everywhere. Female models that surround male artists on music videos and frequent sexual assault are just a few examples.
Going back to the topic of the features of an "ideal woman," she says that it wasn't surprising that the designer of Barbie was a man. I believe that she says this because if it were in the eyes of a woman, the characteristics would have humility and realism. However, since it was designed by a man, the features were only created in the mind of a primitive man. This creates a window into today's world in that men are stereo typically shallowness in that they only appreciate women for their looks.
Prager takes the specific example of Barbie in order to let people realize the realities of the patriarchal world they live in because no one should have to live unequally due to the way they were born.
Emily Prager, through the use of argumentative rhetorical questions, questions the integrity of the iconic Barbie Doll in its use of promoting a man-dominated world. Remarking on a man's design of an unrealistic depiction of an ideal woman, she draws a contrast between her obvious sexual features and the lack of such on Ken. While Barbie has "something indescribably masculine about her-dare I say it, phallic," Ken is missing something: his Jesus given pink elephant.
She suggests that there's a prejudice against women in that they can be viewed as sexual objects but men cannot. This can be seen everywhere. Female models that surround male artists on music videos and frequent sexual assault are just a few examples.
Going back to the topic of the features of an "ideal woman," she says that it wasn't surprising that the designer of Barbie was a man. I believe that she says this because if it were in the eyes of a woman, the characteristics would have humility and realism. However, since it was designed by a man, the features were only created in the mind of a primitive man. This creates a window into today's world in that men are stereo typically shallowness in that they only appreciate women for their looks.
Prager takes the specific example of Barbie in order to let people realize the realities of the patriarchal world they live in because no one should have to live unequally due to the way they were born.
Sunday, October 23, 2016
Is Race Biological or Conceptual?
As Ms.Valentino assigned us the prompt "Is race a socially constructed concept?", little did she know that it would spark out class debates about the topic. *cough cough Elise* The main argument was over whether race was social or biological.
It is globally recognized that race itself, as a strictly scientific and anatomical concept, is irrefutably biological. "Most anthropologists recognize that there are four major classifications in the world, which include caucasian, mongoloid or asian, negroid or black and australoid. The race classification was created by Carleston S. Coon in 1962. The four major races can then be further subdivided into 30 subgroups." Like gender, race is not something that you can just change or simply not identify to. For the example of gender, no matter what gender you "feel" you identify with, you cannot argue that you were born a certain way and can never change that fact. Race is something that you are categorized into no matter what nationality or country you live in. You fall under one of the main race groups or a mix of several. Another example is how we differentiate animals that come from a common ancestor as separate species after evolution has taken them to different paths. Although humans aren't as extreme, it's comparable. There was a rebuttal for the fact that there is no gene or physical characteristics such as skin pigmentation that can determine what you are. That is false. In an article published by TIME , "A longstanding orthodoxy among social scientists holds that human races are a social construct and have no biological basis" is simply wrong due to the "decoding of the human genome." Because of this, "a growing wealth of data has made clear that" this conception is "simply incorrect" and that there is "indeed a biological basis for race." Due to the fact that you can look into the genome and find particular proteins that correlate to different races, one cannot argue that race is subjective.
And this makes sense right? Tens of Thousands of years ago after the great migrations from Africa such as the Indo-European migrations, the Bantu migrations, the Polynesian migrations, and even the ones that brought people to the Americas from Alaska, you'd expect evolution over thousands of years from their surroundings that would result in physical diversification such as skin pigmentation and average height. You cannot tell me that these two people are the same physically and genetically and that they cannot be distinguished from these characteristics let alone if a genome test was done on them.

I am not denying, however, that the racism and discrimination that happens in society is socially constructed. As you'd expect if you were separated for tens of thousands of years, the people that you were with would likely create its own culture and customs. These, I believe, are the roots of the reason that racial groups are viewed as different than others. The social stigmas and stereotypes that come with each race are a direct result of their culture and behavior are the reasons why different ethnic and racial groups distance themselves from others. The rapid globalization of our planet and intermixing of cultures would have the expected effects of fear, racism, and discrimination. This aspect of the argument, I believe, is indeed socially constructed. There is a choice, whether or not we oppress or segregate people based off of their race, but it is not a choice whether or not we are a certain race.
In conclusion, race is not socially constructed, but racism is. I think the main problem with this debate is over the meaning of the term socially constructed. Whether it means that it was first identified by humans (which would actually make everything socially constructed) such as the difference between a tree and a potato or that the concept itself was manufactured by humans such as the difference between normal people and gangsters shapes our opinions. Is color socially constructed if we categorized them? Is math socially constructed because we labeled the different kinds and its laws? There was nothing to predate human language to be able to classify these things. If you say that something is socially conceptual, such as how race is since we had to give names to these races, because humans had to give a name to them, then everything is socially conceptual. There was nothing before these terms and language such that humans could telepathically send chemical messages to one another. I've concluded that the root of these debates is either the difference in the interpretation of the term socially constructed, or the inaccuracy of the question itself. If your opinion still falls opposite to mine, I'll leave you with a question. What's not socially constructed?
It is globally recognized that race itself, as a strictly scientific and anatomical concept, is irrefutably biological. "Most anthropologists recognize that there are four major classifications in the world, which include caucasian, mongoloid or asian, negroid or black and australoid. The race classification was created by Carleston S. Coon in 1962. The four major races can then be further subdivided into 30 subgroups." Like gender, race is not something that you can just change or simply not identify to. For the example of gender, no matter what gender you "feel" you identify with, you cannot argue that you were born a certain way and can never change that fact. Race is something that you are categorized into no matter what nationality or country you live in. You fall under one of the main race groups or a mix of several. Another example is how we differentiate animals that come from a common ancestor as separate species after evolution has taken them to different paths. Although humans aren't as extreme, it's comparable. There was a rebuttal for the fact that there is no gene or physical characteristics such as skin pigmentation that can determine what you are. That is false. In an article published by TIME , "A longstanding orthodoxy among social scientists holds that human races are a social construct and have no biological basis" is simply wrong due to the "decoding of the human genome." Because of this, "a growing wealth of data has made clear that" this conception is "simply incorrect" and that there is "indeed a biological basis for race." Due to the fact that you can look into the genome and find particular proteins that correlate to different races, one cannot argue that race is subjective.
And this makes sense right? Tens of Thousands of years ago after the great migrations from Africa such as the Indo-European migrations, the Bantu migrations, the Polynesian migrations, and even the ones that brought people to the Americas from Alaska, you'd expect evolution over thousands of years from their surroundings that would result in physical diversification such as skin pigmentation and average height. You cannot tell me that these two people are the same physically and genetically and that they cannot be distinguished from these characteristics let alone if a genome test was done on them.
I am not denying, however, that the racism and discrimination that happens in society is socially constructed. As you'd expect if you were separated for tens of thousands of years, the people that you were with would likely create its own culture and customs. These, I believe, are the roots of the reason that racial groups are viewed as different than others. The social stigmas and stereotypes that come with each race are a direct result of their culture and behavior are the reasons why different ethnic and racial groups distance themselves from others. The rapid globalization of our planet and intermixing of cultures would have the expected effects of fear, racism, and discrimination. This aspect of the argument, I believe, is indeed socially constructed. There is a choice, whether or not we oppress or segregate people based off of their race, but it is not a choice whether or not we are a certain race.
In conclusion, race is not socially constructed, but racism is. I think the main problem with this debate is over the meaning of the term socially constructed. Whether it means that it was first identified by humans (which would actually make everything socially constructed) such as the difference between a tree and a potato or that the concept itself was manufactured by humans such as the difference between normal people and gangsters shapes our opinions. Is color socially constructed if we categorized them? Is math socially constructed because we labeled the different kinds and its laws? There was nothing to predate human language to be able to classify these things. If you say that something is socially conceptual, such as how race is since we had to give names to these races, because humans had to give a name to them, then everything is socially conceptual. There was nothing before these terms and language such that humans could telepathically send chemical messages to one another. I've concluded that the root of these debates is either the difference in the interpretation of the term socially constructed, or the inaccuracy of the question itself. If your opinion still falls opposite to mine, I'll leave you with a question. What's not socially constructed?
Sunday, October 16, 2016
Human Nature Explained Through Maus
In order for Maus to portray the gruesome realities the Holocaust, he not only employs the illustrations but also the content in order to quake the hearts of the readers. One key ingredient in his recipe for complete awe is to show the effects and transformations the Holocaust has on its victims such as grief, guilt, and survival.
It is no surprise that when humans are brought to their absolute survival limits, their characters will drastically change to their primitive instinct - to survive. This is evident throughout Maus and is hinted at early in the prologue when Art's father tells him “Friends? Your friends? If you lock them together in a room with no food for a week…Then you could see what it is, friends! …” He says this due to the fact that familial and friendship bonds were constantly being tested and broken throughout Maus. One recurring moment is when fellow Jews would join the side of the Germans in tormenting and exterminating their own kind in exchange for the chance to make it through the war. There is no reason to blame them, however, because wouldn't we all do the same in the end? If you were to choose your and your family's lives over some strangers you haven't even met, isn't the choice obvious? This hardwired selfishness as mentioned in This is Water is ever prevalent. This is a trait that even becomes embedded into Vladek during and long after the war. His inherent instinct to be stingy can be seen when he only offers snow to the dying train riders in exchange for goods and when he exchanges partially eaten food at the grocery store. This is to represent that these qualities can infect even the best of people, even the protagonists. This eventually leads to another trait of human nature that is seen - grief and guilt. Grief and guilt are very common side effects of trauma such as the Holocaust or the suicide of Art's mother. In both cases, it has left people in tatters over the past. Art's constant struggle with the guilt of not being able to experience the Holocaust with his parents nags at him and his even the cause of his obsession with the Holocaust in the first place. Along with that, the grief and guilt he feels as represented in "Hell on Planet Earth" shows his blaming of self due to his mother's suicide. Art Spiegelman is trying to demonstrate these traits to a large audience to let them have a better understanding of the feelings that surround the atrocities of the Holocaust.
It is no surprise that when humans are brought to their absolute survival limits, their characters will drastically change to their primitive instinct - to survive. This is evident throughout Maus and is hinted at early in the prologue when Art's father tells him “Friends? Your friends? If you lock them together in a room with no food for a week…Then you could see what it is, friends! …” He says this due to the fact that familial and friendship bonds were constantly being tested and broken throughout Maus. One recurring moment is when fellow Jews would join the side of the Germans in tormenting and exterminating their own kind in exchange for the chance to make it through the war. There is no reason to blame them, however, because wouldn't we all do the same in the end? If you were to choose your and your family's lives over some strangers you haven't even met, isn't the choice obvious? This hardwired selfishness as mentioned in This is Water is ever prevalent. This is a trait that even becomes embedded into Vladek during and long after the war. His inherent instinct to be stingy can be seen when he only offers snow to the dying train riders in exchange for goods and when he exchanges partially eaten food at the grocery store. This is to represent that these qualities can infect even the best of people, even the protagonists. This eventually leads to another trait of human nature that is seen - grief and guilt. Grief and guilt are very common side effects of trauma such as the Holocaust or the suicide of Art's mother. In both cases, it has left people in tatters over the past. Art's constant struggle with the guilt of not being able to experience the Holocaust with his parents nags at him and his even the cause of his obsession with the Holocaust in the first place. Along with that, the grief and guilt he feels as represented in "Hell on Planet Earth" shows his blaming of self due to his mother's suicide. Art Spiegelman is trying to demonstrate these traits to a large audience to let them have a better understanding of the feelings that surround the atrocities of the Holocaust.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
